We Roasted Ourselves First.
Before asking you to trust our AI critics, we ran PageRekt.com through our own gauntlet. The results were brutal. We found 12 critical issues and used every insight to rebuild what you see today.
Original score: 4.0/10 (ouch)
12 critical issues identified
Every issue addressed and fixed
Our Original Scores
When we first roasted PageRekt.com, the results were... humbling.
Overall Score
4.0/10
Needs Immediate Attention
Issues Identified
12
What Our AI Found
Each of our 6 AI experts tore into different aspects of the site
Vague CTAs that failed to communicate value
"Get Started" and "Learn More" buttons gave users no reason to click. No urgency, no benefit, just generic button text.
Zero social proof or credibility indicators
No testimonials, no logos, no numbers. Visitors had no way to trust we could deliver on our promises.
Confusing navigation and unclear user journey
Users couldn't figure out what to do first. The path from landing to conversion was a maze, not a funnel.
Generic, forgettable messaging
Headlines that could apply to any SaaS product. Nothing memorable, nothing that addressed visitor pain points.
Tiny tap targets and cramped mobile layout
Buttons were too small, spacing was wrong, and the mobile experience felt like an afterthought.
Missing meta descriptions and poor heading structure
Search engines had no idea what we did. H1 tags were misused, meta descriptions were blank.
What We Fixed
We took every piece of feedback seriously
Clear, benefit-driven CTAs
"Roast My Website" and "Get Your Free Roast" tell users exactly what they'll get. No ambiguity.
Added real examples and transparency
This very case study, plus showing our methodology openly. We practice what we preach.
Simplified sign-up flow to 3 steps
Enter URL → Pick persona → Get roast. No account required upfront. Reduced friction to zero.
Crystal clear value proposition
"Your website sucks. Let us tell you why." Memorable, direct, and addresses the exact problem we solve.
Redesigned for thumb-friendly interaction
Larger buttons, proper spacing, mobile-first layouts. Every element tested on real devices.
Proper metadata and content structure
Every page has unique titles, descriptions, and proper heading hierarchy. Schema markup added.
Key Takeaways
What we learned from roasting ourselves
1. Be Brutally Honest With Yourself
We built a tool for honest feedback and still needed our own tool to see our blind spots. Everyone has them.
2. Small Changes, Big Impact
Changing "Get Started" to "Roast My Website" alone increased clicks by 47%. Details matter.
3. Trust Signals Are Non-Negotiable
Without social proof, even the best product struggles. This case study exists because we needed one.
4. Test on Real Devices
Our mobile experience was embarrassing. We only found out by actually using it on phones.
Stop Guessing, Start Converting
See what's hurting your conversions. Free. 2 minutes.